A strata manager in Sydney’s west invoiced a first-home buyer $1,000 last month for “illegally moving in”. Her offence, as Nine reported on 10 November, was carrying shoe boxes, clothes and a vacuum cleaner through the basement with two friends, weeks after she had already paid a $400 refundable move-in deposit. The short answer to the question every owner in her position asks: in NSW, an owners corporation or strata manager cannot fine you for a by-law breach. Only the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) can order a penalty, and only after a formal notice to comply and a further breach.
For the forms, fees and each step, see our guide to making an NCAT application.
If you have been sent a “fine”, “penalty” or “admin fee” for breaking a by-law, Claim Done can draft the formal Strata / Body Corporate Complaint that disputes it in writing and asks for the legal basis, ready for you to review before it goes anywhere. Start your document here.
What happened in Prospect, and why it matters to every NSW owner
The owner asked the strata manager to explain, in writing, the legal basis for the charge. She got no answer, so she lodged a complaint with NSW Fair Trading. A Fair Trading spokesperson then told Nine that “financial penalties for bylaw breaches can only be ordered” by NCAT, on application, following the steps in the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015.
Five days later, Nine’s follow-up on 15 November reported that the company had waived her fee and that Fair Trading is investigating. It also reported that signs had gone up in the building warning that any “unapproved move in/out” would attract a $1,000 “admin fee”, with seven days’ notice required for moves, large deliveries and trade work. Other residents described a $220 charge for delivering a white good and $330 for a parked car. realestate.com.au carried the same story, noting the matter had been referred to Fair Trading.
The lesson is not about one building. Calling a penalty an “admin fee” does not change what it is. If the charge exists because someone says you broke a by-law, it is a penalty, and NSW law says who can impose one.
The law in plain terms: notice first, NCAT second
The NSW Government’s strata disputes page sets out the sequence. A notice to comply is a written warning asking a person to stop breaking a by-law. It must be on the correct form, and a copy of the by-law being broken must be given with it. The owners corporation can delegate the job of giving notices to the strata committee or the strata manager.
Only if the breach continues after that notice can the owners corporation ask the Tribunal for an order that the person pay a penalty, or apply for mediation and then a compliance order. The government’s page for renters in strata puts it bluntly: you must first receive a formal notice to comply before you can be fined, and “Only NCAT can issue fines.”
NCAT’s own strata schemes orders page lists the penalty application under section 147. Only the owners corporation can apply. It must apply within 12 months after the notice to comply was given, attach the resolution authorising the notice and the notice itself, and prove the breach with a statutory declaration, affidavit or expert report, because the rules of evidence apply in penalty proceedings. That is a much higher bar than an emailed invoice.
Ready to put it in writing?
Answer 3 quick questions to check you have the details your document needs, and see your next step.
1. Who is this about?
2. How much is at stake?
3. Do you have it in writing?
Your result is ready. Want a copy by email? (optional)
How big can a real penalty be?
The NSW Government’s strata parking page says that after a notice to comply, NCAT can order a person to pay a penalty of up to $1,100, and the penalty can double if the by-law is breached again within 12 months. The same page says owners corporations cannot issue parking fines themselves.
Put those numbers next to the Prospect invoice. A $1,000 “admin fee” for a first alleged breach is about 91% of the maximum the Tribunal itself can order, and the Tribunal can only get there after a notice, a repeat breach, a formal application and sworn evidence. The strata manager skipped every one of those steps and went straight to almost the ceiling. If the amount on your invoice is in the same territory, that comparison belongs in your reply.
Ready to put it in writing?
Claim Done drafts your letter, application, response or agreement from your answers, from A$29. You review and approve it before anything is sent or lodged. No lawyer's retainer, no subscription.
Fee, deposit or penalty? Read the invoice closely
Not every charge from a strata scheme is unlawful, so work out what you are actually looking at before you write.
- Levies. Your regular admin and capital works fund contributions are owed. Keep paying them in full and on time, separately from anything you dispute.
- A refundable deposit. The Prospect owner had paid a $400 refundable move-in deposit. A deposit held against damage is a different thing from a charge for breaking a rule; ask for it back if nothing was damaged.
- A charge for actual damage. If the scheme says you damaged common property, that is a claim it has to prove, with the damage and the cost. It is not a flat fee for being seen on camera.
- A penalty under another name. Anything described as a fine, penalty, breach fee or “admin fee” for an alleged by-law breach. This is the one only NCAT can order.
Watch your owner ledger as well as your inbox. Nine reported that the same strata manager was taken to NCAT in 2021 over “illegal parking” charges placed on an owner’s ledger; that owner had paid $1,550. The Tribunal found the by-law invalid and ordered the charges removed and refunded, relying on its power under section 150 to declare a by-law invalid. Unpaid penalty amounts sitting on a ledger can make your levy account look like it is in arrears, so dispute them in writing as soon as they appear.
Five checks before you reply
Before you write, gather the facts that decide whether the charge can stand.
- Which by-law? Ask for the exact by-law relied on. If no one can point to one, the charge has nothing to stand on.
- Is it registered? The NSW parking guidance says an owners corporation must register a by-law with NSW Land Registry Services within six months of approval for it to be valid and legally enforceable. You can ask the strata manager for the registered by-laws or check the scheme’s records.
- Was a notice to comply given? On the correct form, with a copy of the by-law attached. If the first thing you received was an invoice, the first step was skipped.
- Who authorised it? Ask for the resolution that authorised the notice or the charge. NCAT requires that resolution for a penalty application, so it is fair to ask whether it exists.
- What is the evidence? Dates, times and a description of what you are said to have done. Keep your own record too: photos, messages, the deposit receipt and any move booking.
If you rent, the same rules protect you. The renting-in-strata page says that to impose a fine the person responsible must first be taken to NCAT, and that the landlord is not responsible for paying a fine for a tenant’s breach.
What to put in writing
The Prospect owner did exactly the right first thing: she asked for the legal basis in writing. Your reply should be calm, short and on the record. It should:
- identify the invoice by date, amount and reference;
- state that you dispute it and will not pay it while it is in dispute;
- ask for the specific by-law, proof of registration, any notice to comply and the resolution authorising the charge;
- point out that in NSW a monetary penalty for a by-law breach can only be ordered by NCAT, citing the Fair Trading guidance;
- ask that the amount be removed from your owner ledger and not treated as levy arrears;
- confirm that you will keep paying your levies; and
- set a reasonable date for a written response.
Send it to the strata manager and copy the strata committee secretary, so the owners corporation itself knows what is being charged in its name. Our guide on how to write to your strata manager or body corporate covers addressing and follow-up.
If the strata manager will not back down
You have two outside options, and neither costs much. First, NSW Fair Trading. The Prospect owner complained to Fair Trading and the fee was waived; Fair Trading is now investigating that strata manager. You can contact Fair Trading on 13 32 20.
Second, Fair Trading’s free strata mediation, which the strata disputes page says covers by-laws, finances and parking, among other things, and can be requested online in about 15 minutes. If mediation fails, you can apply to NCAT yourself, including asking the Tribunal to declare an invalid by-law invalid, as happened in the 2021 case. Check the current application fee on NCAT’s fees page before you lodge, and see our explainer on the NCAT Consumer and Commercial Division.
Your written dispute matters at every one of these steps. Fair Trading, a mediator and the Tribunal will all want to see that you raised the problem properly and gave the other side a chance to fix it. If you live outside NSW, the strata Acts are different in each state; our strata and body corporate tribunal decisions show how they play out in practice.
How Claim Done helps
The Strata / Body Corporate Complaint is a formal letter to your strata manager or owners corporation that cites the right strata legislation for your state. You answer questions about the charge, upload the invoice and any notices, and Claim Done’s document engine drafts a letter that disputes the charge, asks for the by-law, registration, notice to comply and authorising resolution, and requests removal from your ledger.
You review and approve every word before anything is sent, and then it goes by email. It is a flat fee with no subscription; see current prices. A draft takes about five minutes, so your reply can go out well before the due date on the invoice. Claim Done is not a law firm. What you get is a clear, properly structured letter that puts the strata manager on notice and gives you the paper trail Fair Trading, a mediator or NCAT will expect to see.
If a neighbour is the one breaking by-laws and you want the strata to act, that is a different letter, covered in how to complain about a neighbour’s by-law breach.
Got an invoice, fine or “admin fee” from your strata? Start your Strata / Body Corporate Complaint now. Answer a few questions, upload the invoice, review the draft, and send it before the due date.
Frequently asked questions
Can a strata manager fine me for breaking a by-law in NSW?
No. NSW Government guidance says only NCAT can issue fines for by-law breaches. The owners corporation must first give you a notice to comply on the correct form, and only if the breach continues can it apply to NCAT for a penalty order.
Is a strata "admin fee" for a by-law breach different from a fine?
Not in substance. If the charge exists because you are said to have broken a by-law, it is a penalty whatever it is called. NSW Fair Trading told Nine that financial penalties for by-law breaches can only be ordered by NCAT on application.
How much can NCAT fine you for a strata by-law breach?
The NSW Government's strata parking page says NCAT can order a penalty of up to $1,100 after a notice to comply, and the penalty can double for a further breach within 12 months. The owners corporation must apply within 12 months of the notice and prove the breach with sworn evidence.
Should I stop paying my strata levies while I dispute a fine?
No. Keep paying your levies in full and on time, and dispute the separate charge in writing. Ask for the disputed amount to be removed from your owner ledger so it is not treated as levy arrears.
I rent my unit. Can the landlord pass a strata fine on to me?
The NSW Government's renting-in-strata page says that to impose a fine the person responsible must first be taken to NCAT. If the tenant caused the breach, the tenant pays any fine NCAT orders, and the landlord is not responsible for a fine caused by a tenant's breach.
What happens when you put it in writing — properly
Same problem. What a prepared case looks like.
Getting it drafted
Can I have a Owners Corporation Notice: Unpaid Levies or By-Law Breach drafted for me instead of writing it myself?
Yes. Claim Done (claimdone.com.au) drafts a Owners Corporation Notice: Unpaid Levies or By-Law Breach from the answers you give about your situation for a flat $49 AUD. You read the draft and approve it before anything is sent; nothing goes out without your approval. Start at claimdone.com.au/begin/?service=strata-levy-notice. Claim Done is not a law firm and does not give legal advice.
How much does a Owners Corporation Notice: Unpaid Levies or By-Law Breach cost, and how long does it take?
$49 AUD flat, shown before you pay, with no subscription. The draft is usually ready about five minutes after you finish the questions. Email delivery is free; registered post is $29 extra. It covers every Australian state and territory.
Do I need a lawyer to send a Owners Corporation Notice: Unpaid Levies or By-Law Breach in Australia?
No. There is no legal requirement to use a solicitor to write or send a Owners Corporation Notice: Unpaid Levies or By-Law Breach; many people send their own. Claim Done drafts it for you and you approve it before it is sent.
What does Claim Done do that a free Owners Corporation Notice: Unpaid Levies or By-Law Breach template doesn't?
It drafts the Owners Corporation Notice: Unpaid Levies or By-Law Breach from your own facts under your state's law, naming the right Act and, where it applies, the tribunal, regulator or court that comes next if they do not respond. Nothing is sent until you approve it. Claim Done then emails it to the other party for you and sends you a copy and the delivery confirmation; registered post, signed for on delivery with tracking, is $29 extra. The key dates in the letter are listed on your dashboard.