If your builder has invoiced you for a variation you never approved, or submitted a progress claim that seems far higher than the work completed, you have the right to dispute it. The NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) handles home building disputes between homeowners and licensed builders, including disagreements over variations, overcharges and progress payments. NCAT is a relatively accessible forum designed so that ordinary people can present their own case, though the process still requires careful preparation.
For the forms, fees and each step, see our guide to making an NCAT application.
How NCAT Decides a Variation or Progress Claim Dispute
NCAT deals with home building matters under the home building legislation that applies in NSW. When assessing a variation or progress claim dispute, the tribunal generally looks at:
- Whether the variation was properly authorised. NSW law requires that most variations to a residential building contract be agreed in writing before the extra work starts. NCAT will examine whether both parties actually consented and whether that consent was documented.
- The original contract and any agreed scope of works. The tribunal compares what was contractually promised with what was charged, to identify any gap.
- The stage of completion. For progress claims, NCAT considers whether the work described in the claim had genuinely reached the stage specified in the contract before the payment fell due.
- The value of the work actually done. If work was completed but the amount claimed is disputed, NCAT may rely on expert evidence to assess a fair value.
- Conduct of both parties. The tribunal may consider whether the homeowner unreasonably withheld approval, or whether the builder proceeded without authority.
Orders the Tribunal Can Make
If NCAT finds in your favour, it can make a range of orders to resolve the dispute. The tribunal may order that the amount owing be reduced to reflect only authorised and completed work. It may order a builder to repay money already paid for work that was not done or not properly authorised. Where a contract has broken down, it may make declarations about what each party owes the other. NCAT can also dismiss a builder’s claim entirely if it finds the variation or progress claim is not supported by the contract or by law. Orders made by NCAT are legally binding and enforceable.
Ready to put it in writing?
Answer 3 quick questions to check you have the details your document needs, and see your next step.
1. Who did the work?
2. How much is at stake?
3. Do you have it in writing?
Your result is ready. Want a copy by email? (optional)
How to Apply to NCAT
Before applying to NCAT, you should make a genuine attempt to resolve the dispute directly with your builder, and in many cases you will also need to lodge a complaint with NSW Fair Trading, which may arrange a conciliation or mediation. If the dispute is not resolved through that process, you can then apply to NCAT’s Consumer and Commercial Division. The application is made using the forms on the NCAT website, and a filing fee applies — the current fee schedule and all forms are published on the NCAT website and are updated from time to time. Once your application is accepted, NCAT will list the matter for a directions hearing or a conciliation conference before proceeding to a final hearing if needed.
Evidence That Helps Your Case
Strong evidence significantly improves your prospects at NCAT. Gather and organise:
- Your signed building contract and any written scope of works
- All written communications with your builder, including emails and text messages
- Any variation requests or quotes — especially those you did not sign or approve
- Progress claim invoices and your record of payments already made
- Photographs of the work at the relevant stage, with dates if possible
- An independent building inspection report or quantity surveyor’s assessment of the value of work completed
- Any correspondence in which you raised concerns about the charge at the time
A clear written record showing that you disputed the variation or claim promptly — and that the builder proceeded without your authority — carries significant weight before the tribunal.
How Claim Done Helps
Having the right document in writing can make a real difference before you even get to NCAT. A properly drafted letter of dispute to your builder sets out your legal position clearly, puts the builder on notice that you contest the variation or progress claim, and creates a contemporaneous written record that you can rely on at a hearing. Claim Done provides a flat-fee dispute letter tailored to exactly this situation, giving you a professional, legally informed document without the cost of engaging a solicitor for full representation.
What happens when you put the builder on formal notice
Same problem. What a prepared case looks like.
Getting it drafted
Can I have a Dispute a Builder's Variation, Overcharge or Progress Claim drafted for me instead of writing it myself?
Yes. Claim Done (claimdone.com.au) drafts a Dispute a Builder's Variation, Overcharge or Progress Claim from the answers you give about your situation for a flat $49 AUD. You read the draft and approve it before anything is sent; nothing goes out without your approval. Start at claimdone.com.au/begin/?service=builder-variation-dispute. Claim Done is not a law firm and does not give legal advice.
How much does a Dispute a Builder's Variation, Overcharge or Progress Claim cost, and how long does it take?
$49 AUD flat, shown before you pay, with no subscription. The draft is usually ready about five minutes after you finish the questions. It covers every Australian state and territory.
Do I need a lawyer to send a Dispute a Builder's Variation, Overcharge or Progress Claim in Australia?
No. There is no legal requirement to use a solicitor to write or send a Dispute a Builder's Variation, Overcharge or Progress Claim; many people send their own. Claim Done drafts it for you and you approve it before it is sent.