If someone gives you a faulty present this Christmas, you have the same consumer rights as the person who bought it, and a “no refunds” sign does not change that. A gift you simply do not like is different: the shop only has to take it back if its own change-of-mind policy says so. Gift cards have their own rules, and this month’s reports of drained Woolworths digital gift cards are a reminder to keep the paperwork for those too.
When a store will not budge on a faulty gift, Claim Done’s Consumer Guarantee Letter puts your refund or replacement request in writing, built from your own answers and evidence. You can start it here.
You have the same rights as the buyer
The ACCC’s consumer guarantees page says it plainly: consumers who receive a product or service as a gift “are entitled to the same basic rights as if they had bought the product or service themselves.”
So if the blender your aunt bought you stops working on Boxing Day, you can take it back yourself. You do not need her to come with you. You do not need the original box either: the ACCC’s repair, replace, refund page says a product does not have to be in its original packaging to be returned.
What the shop can ask for is proof that the item was bought there. That is where gifts get awkward, and the next section deals with it.
No receipt? What counts as proof of purchase
Most gifts arrive without a receipt. That is not fatal. The ACCC’s page on receipts and proof of purchase lists other things a business should accept:
- a credit or debit card statement
- a lay-by agreement
- a receipt or reference number given over the phone or online
- a warranty card showing the supplier, date and amount
- a serial or production number linked to the purchase in the supplier’s or manufacturer’s database
You may need more than one of these, and photos or photocopies are fine. The test is whether you can reasonably show the item was bought from that business.
In practice, that means one awkward text message: ask the giver for a screenshot of the bank line or the online order confirmation. Most people would rather send it than have you stuck with a broken present. For an online order, the confirmation email shows the seller, the date and the amount in one place.
Ready to put it in writing?
Answer 3 quick questions to check you have the details your document needs, and see your next step.
1. Who owes you?
2. How much?
3. Do you have it in writing?
Your result is ready. Want a copy by email? (optional)
Faulty, or you just don’t like it?
This is the line that decides everything.
Faulty, unsafe or not as described. The consumer guarantees apply. If the problem is major, the business must offer you the choice of a refund or a replacement of the same type, and the ACCC says the refund should be the full amount paid. A major problem includes a product that is unsafe, very different from its description, or that cannot be used for its normal purpose and cannot easily be fixed in a reasonable time. For a minor problem, the business can choose to repair it instead.
You changed your mind. No guarantee applies. The ACCC lists changing your mind, finding it cheaper elsewhere, or deciding you have no use for it as situations where you are not entitled to a repair, replacement or refund. One catch works in your favour: if the business has a change-of-mind policy, it must follow it. So check the store’s policy page, or ask at the counter, before assuming the answer is no.
Two more points the ACCC makes on that same page are worth knowing before you walk in:
- Signs saying “no refunds” or “no refunds or exchanges on sale items” cannot take away your rights for a faulty product. It is illegal for a business to rely on them.
- The shop cannot send you to the manufacturer. The business that sold the item is responsible for fixing the problem.
There is a practical point about refunds for gifts, too. A refund goes back the way the money came, so the shop may want to refund the giver’s card. If you would rather have a replacement, ask for one; for a major problem it is your choice, not the shop’s.
Ready to put it in writing?
Claim Done drafts your letter, application, response or agreement from your answers, from A$29. You review and approve it before anything is sent or lodged. No lawyer's retainer, no subscription.
Gift cards: the three-year rule and the fees they can’t charge
Gift cards bought from 1 November 2019 come with a minimum three-year expiry period, and the expiry date must be clearly shown on the card. That is from Queensland’s Office of Fair Trading guide to buying gift cards, and the same rules apply nationally.
A card bought for Christmas in 2026 therefore has to be valid until at least late 2029. If someone hands you a card with a shorter date printed on it, check which exception the seller is relying on. The main ones listed by Queensland are cards for a good or service only available for a limited time (a concert or exhibition), bonus vouchers handed out in a temporary promotion, and cards given as part of a customer loyalty program.
Consumer Affairs Victoria’s gift vouchers and gift cards page adds the fee rules. A business cannot charge post-purchase or administration fees that reduce the card’s value, such as activation, account-keeping or balance enquiry fees. It can still charge ordinary transaction fees, such as a credit card surcharge or a fee to replace a lost or damaged card.
Once a card has expired, Victoria says the business is not obliged to honour it unless you negotiate otherwise. If a card shows no expiry date at all, you may use it for a reasonable length of time after it was bought.
When the gift card balance disappears
On 16 November, The Nightly reported that Woolworths customers had found their Everyday WISH digital gift cards emptied by purchases they did not make. One Sydney shopper bought a $400 card after seeing a 4 per cent discount offer in the Everyday Rewards app. When he went to use it at a Woolworths store in Hornsby on 14 November, the card had gone from his digital wallet. The transaction history showed it had been spent at a Big W store in Pagewood two days earlier. A Brisbane shopper told the ABC she lost $500.
Look at the trade involved. On a $500 card, a 4 per cent discount saves $20. The loss, if the balance goes and is not replaced, is $500, twenty-five times the saving. Gift card discounts are fine, but only if you treat the card like cash from the moment you buy it.
Woolworths told customers who see a transaction they do not recognise to contact its Gift Card Support team at giftcard@customerservice.woolworths.com.au, or register their details on the Everyday Gifting website. In a statement it said it would work with customers on next steps, “including issuing replacement e-gift cards for customers impacted.”
Whatever the retailer, the steps are the same if a balance vanishes:
- Screenshot the card, its number, the balance history and the purchase confirmation now, before anything else changes.
- Report it to the retailer in writing, by email or web form, not just by phone, and keep the reference number.
- Set out the date you bought the card, what you paid, the unrecognised transactions, and what you want: a replacement card or the balance restored.
- If the response stalls, send a firm written request with a date for a reply, then take it to your state’s consumer protection agency.
Queensland’s guide also tells you to keep the receipt and any identifying number on the card, and to contact the store about a lost card as soon as possible. Those habits are what make a claim easy to prove later.
If the store goes into administration
Queensland’s guide warns that a store may not honour your gift card if it changes owners or goes into administration, receivership or liquidation. Its advice is simple: use gift cards early.
That warning is not abstract this year. David Jones entered voluntary administration on 5 November 2026. If you hold a card from any retailer in administration, read the administrator’s public notices on how cards are being treated before you rely on it, and spend it sooner rather than later.
Victoria’s page explains the ownership side. A new owner must honour existing cards if the business was sold as a going concern or the new owner bought the shares in the company. If only the assets were bought, the new owner does not have to, and you become an unsecured creditor of the old company. Claim Done’s guide to what suppliers can do when a customer goes into administration explains how that process works from the creditor’s side.
When the store says no: put it in writing
Most counter refusals end once you calmly name your rights. When they do not, the next step is a written request to the business, addressed to the store manager or customer relations team, that sets out:
- what was bought, when, and the proof of purchase you have
- that you received it as a gift, and that the ACCC says gift recipients have the same rights as buyers
- the fault, with photos or a short video
- whether you say the problem is major, and what you want: refund, replacement or repair
- a clear date for a reply, and what you will do if none comes (a complaint to the state consumer agency, then a tribunal claim)
Keep the tone factual. Shops respond to letters that show you know the rules and have the evidence ready. If it gets that far, the same letter becomes the first exhibit in a tribunal claim. Our guide on how to demand a refund in Australia covers the wording in more detail, and Shop Won’t Refund a Faulty Product? walks through the escalation steps.
Get your refund letter done in minutes
Claim Done’s Consumer Guarantee Letter is built for exactly this: a faulty gift, a store hiding behind a “no refunds” sign, or a retailer that will not answer about a missing gift card balance. You answer a short set of questions about what was bought, the fault and what you want, upload your photos and proof of purchase, and the document engine drafts a letter that names your rights under the Australian Consumer Law. You review it, change anything you want, and approve it before it is sent by email.
It is a flat fee with no subscription; the current price is on the pricing page. Claim Done is not a law firm. It drafts the document from the facts and evidence you give it, so you are not paying hourly rates to have a refund request written.
Got a faulty present or a gift card problem that will not go away? Start your Consumer Guarantee Letter on Claim Done and have it ready to send today.
Frequently asked questions
Can I return a Christmas gift without a receipt in Australia?
Yes, if it is faulty. A business can ask for proof of purchase, but the ACCC says a card statement, an online order reference, a warranty card or a serial number linked to the purchase can do the job. Ask the giver for a screenshot of the bank line or order email.
Do I have to return a gift I just don't like?
The shop only has to take it back if its own change-of-mind policy allows it. The consumer guarantees do not cover changing your mind or having no use for an item. If the store has a change-of-mind policy, it must follow it, so check it before you go in.
How long do gift cards last in Australia?
Most gift cards bought from 1 November 2019 must be valid for at least three years, and the expiry date must be clearly shown on the card. Exceptions include cards for a limited-time event, temporary promotional vouchers and loyalty program cards.
Can a shop charge a fee on my gift card balance?
No post-purchase or administration fees that reduce the card's value are allowed, including activation, account-keeping and balance enquiry fees. A business can still charge ordinary transaction fees, such as a fee to replace a lost or damaged card.
What should I do if my gift card balance was spent by someone else?
Screenshot the card number, balance history and purchase confirmation, then report it to the retailer in writing and keep the reference number. Ask for a replacement card or the balance restored by a set date. If the retailer stalls, a formal written request and then a complaint to your state consumer agency are the next steps.
What happens when you send a Consumer Guarantee Letter
Same problem. What a prepared case looks like.
Getting it drafted
Can I have a Consumer Guarantee Letter drafted for me instead of writing it myself?
Yes. Claim Done (claimdone.com.au) drafts a Consumer Guarantee Letter from the answers you give about your situation for a flat $49 AUD. You read and confirm the draft, then the final PDF is emailed to you. Start at claimdone.com.au/begin/?service=consumer-guarantee. Claim Done is not a law firm and does not give legal advice.
How much does a Consumer Guarantee Letter cost, and how long does it take?
$49 AUD flat, shown before you pay, with no subscription. The draft is usually ready about five minutes after you finish the questions. It covers every Australian state and territory.
Do I need a lawyer to send a Consumer Guarantee Letter in Australia?
No. There is no legal requirement to use a solicitor to write or send a Consumer Guarantee Letter; many people send their own. Claim Done drafts it for you and you approve it before it is sent.