02 8880 1347
← Legal Guides Published · Updated

NCAT Cross-Claim: When a Respondent Can Claim Back, When You Can’t, and How to Lodge It in Time

A cross-claim lets an NCAT respondent bring their own claim against the applicant so both are heard together, but not in every case type. Here is where NCAT allows one, where it does not, and the timing that decides whether yours is heard with the original claim.

Start your Tribunal Response — $129 →A few taps to start · you see the price before you pay · Private & encrypted

Topics: consumer and commercial division, cross-application, home building dispute NSW, NCAT cross claim, NCAT respondent, tribunal response

If someone has taken you to NCAT and you believe they owe you money, a cross-claim is how you put your own claim in front of the Tribunal alongside theirs. NCAT’s own wording is careful: you “may be able to” lodge one depending on the type of case, and you should do it quickly so the two can be heard together. Get the case type wrong, or lodge late, and you end up running a second dispute on a second timetable.

This guide covers which NCAT case types allow a cross-claim, the one big category that doesn’t, the deadline NCAT sets for home building disputes, and what a cross-claim costs. If you are the respondent and need your side set out in writing, Claim Done’s Tribunal Response drafts your position statement, chronology and evidence list from your answers for A$129, and you can start it here.

NCAT asks you to say what orders you want and explain why, clearly enough for the Member and the other side to follow. Tell us what happened in your own words. We set it out the way the tribunal asks.
Where are you up to?
Pick the closest one and we’ll start the right document for you. You see the price and approve it before anything is sent.
Not ready yet? Get the free checklist for your stage
A one-page checklist by email, with the official links for your tribunal.

What a cross-claim actually is

A cross-claim is not a defence. A defence says “I don’t owe what they say I owe”. A cross-claim says “and they owe me”. It is a separate application, made by the respondent against the applicant, about the same dealings.

NCAT’s home building guideline puts it plainly: if a respondent wants orders against the applicant, “the respondent must lodge a separate application”, which it calls a cross-application. That one sentence carries three consequences most people miss:

  • It is your own application, on the approved form, with its own fee.
  • You carry the burden of proving it, the same way the applicant carries theirs.
  • It can be heard with the original claim, but only if it arrives in time.

NCAT uses “cross-claim” on its respondent pages and “cross-application” in the home building guideline. They describe the same thing.

Where NCAT says you can’t cross-claim: consumer and motor vehicle claims

This is the part that surprises traders. NCAT’s Consumer and Commercial Division fact sheet for respondents says “you cannot lodge a cross-claim in a consumer claim or motor vehicles matter”. The fact sheet is dated January 2016, and it is still the respondents’ fact sheet NCAT publishes; its current page on responding to a case (last updated 28 January 2025) repeats the general position that it depends on the type of case and tells respondents to check the relevant legislation.

The reason is structural. A consumer claim at NCAT is brought by the consumer who bought the goods or services. A business that supplied the work and wasn’t paid has a debt, and NCAT is not where general debts go. Our guide on taking a customer to NCAT for non-payment walks through that split.

So picture a renovator in Newcastle. The customer lodges a consumer claim for $8,000, saying the bathroom tiling was defective. The renovator says the tiling was fine and the customer still owes the last $3,500 invoice. Under NCAT’s fact sheet, the renovator has no cross-claim in that consumer claim. What the renovator can do:

  1. Defend the consumer claim properly, with the contract, photos, messages and the unpaid invoice in the evidence, so the Tribunal sees the whole account.
  2. Pursue the unpaid balance as a debt. In New South Wales, the Local Court’s Small Claims Division hears claims up to $20,000, and its General Division hears claims over $20,000 up to $100,000.

That means two forums, two fees and two timetables if the renovator wants a money order for the $3,500. It is worth knowing before you walk into conciliation, because a settlement that nets the two amounts off against each other may be worth more to you than winning one forum and starting again in the other.

Free · 30 seconds

Ready to put it in writing?

Answer 3 quick questions to check you have the details your document needs, and see your next step.

1. Who is the claim or demand from?

Give us a name — even a first name or business name is fine.

2. How much are they claiming?

3. Do you have it in writing?

Your result is ready. Want a copy by email? (optional)

That email does not look right.
Leave it blank to see your result now. Add your email and we also send you the result and your next step, so you can come back to it. No spam, no list.

Continue to your $129 Tribunal Response →
Your answers are carried across — you will not have to type them again. You read and approve it before anything is sent. No card needed to start.

Home building disputes: the deadline is the first listing

Home building is where cross-claims are most common, because both sides usually have a grievance: the owner says the work is defective, the builder says the owner hasn’t paid. NCAT’s Consumer and Commercial Division Guideline on Home Building Applications (effective 1 August 2017) sets the timing:

  • Cross-applications “should be lodged no later than the first date on which the application is listed before the Tribunal.”
  • Generally all applications and cross-applications about a matter are heard and decided together, “unless circumstances (for example, delay in lodging a cross-application) preclude” it.

Now put that next to the guideline’s listing rule. If the amount claimed or in dispute is under $30,000, the first listing is a conciliation and hearing. Over $30,000, the first listing is for directions.

Here is the consequence nobody spells out. For a dispute over $30,000, the first directions hearing is a procedural step, and the Tribunal can make directions about “the filing of any cross application, including points of cross claim and points of defence”. For a smaller dispute, the first listing is a conciliation and hearing, so the gap between the notice landing in your letterbox and your cross-application deadline is the whole of your preparation time. A builder owed $12,000 by an owner who has lodged a $20,000 defects claim has to get the cross-application lodged before the first listing, not after.

On that first date, the guideline also expects the respondent to hand up a brief statement that outlines the response to the claims and identifies witnesses. If you are cross-claiming, write that statement to cover both: why the applicant’s claim fails, and what you are claiming and why.

The guideline also notes that under section 48MA of the Home Building Act, rectification of defective work by the party who did it is the “preferred outcome”. A builder cross-claiming for an unpaid balance should expect the Tribunal to consider a work order alongside any money order, and should say in the cross-application whether they are willing and able to return to fix items.

Ready to put it in writing?

Claim Done drafts your letter, application, response or agreement from your answers, from A$29. You review and approve it before anything is sent or lodged. No lawyer's retainer, no subscription.

Start your document now → See all services and pricing

Tenancy, strata and other case types

For other Consumer and Commercial Division case types, NCAT’s respondent page gives the same direction: it depends on the type of case, check the legislation, and act quickly. In practice the safe approach is the same everywhere:

  • Lodge your own application promptly, in the right case type, naming the applicant as your respondent.
  • Ask in writing that it be heard together with the existing case, quoting the existing case number.

NCAT’s guidance on lodging requests online (last updated 24 September 2025) explains how: sign in to NCAT Online Services, open your case under My cases, choose “Lodge a secondary form”, and if no form fits, attach “a brief letter” that clearly states what you are asking the Tribunal to do and why. A two-paragraph letter asking for your application to be listed with the existing matter, with both case numbers, does that job.

What a cross-claim costs

Because a cross-claim is its own application, the application fee for that case type applies. NCAT’s fee schedule applies as at 1 July 2026. For example, a residential tenancy application or a consumer claim of not more than $10,000 is $64 at the standard rate, $128 for a corporation and $16 at the reduced rate. Home building fees are set out on the same schedule by amount, so check the line that matches your claim before you lodge. Our summary of NCAT fees for 2026 sets out the consumer claim bands.

Two cost points matter more than the fee itself:

  • If you trade through a company and the money is owed to the company, the company is the cross-claimant and pays the corporation rate.
  • Representation in the Consumer and Commercial Division needs the Tribunal’s permission, and NCAT’s representation guideline lists claims over $30,000 as one situation where leave is usually granted. A cross-claim can push the total amount in dispute past that line.
Tribunal Response — $129You approve it before it is sent · Ready in about 5 min
8,056 people visited ClaimDone in the past 30 days
Set out what you accept, what you dispute and what you propose, in one dated document.
I'll draft your Tribunal Response right now. Who is the claim or demand from?
No card needed to start · Type a name and hit send

Is a cross-claim worth it?

NCAT’s own fact sheet warns that a cross-claim “may delay the resolution of the dispute”. That is the real trade-off. Ask yourself three questions before you lodge:

  1. Is my claim about the same dealings? A cross-claim about an unrelated job is better as its own case.
  2. Can I prove it with documents I already hold? Invoices, the contract, variations agreed in writing, messages and photos. If your claim needs an expert report you don’t have yet, you may not be ready by the first listing.
  3. Would a settlement that offsets both claims suit me better? Conciliation happens at the first conciliation and hearing listing. A cross-claim that is already lodged gives you something concrete to put on the table.

If the answer to all three is yes, lodge it early. If you miss the window, the Tribunal may hear your application separately, which is the delay NCAT warns about.

Preparing for the day

Whichever side of the dispute you start on, the Tribunal decides on the evidence the parties bring. NCAT’s fact sheet tells respondents to bring their documents and that anything given to the Tribunal is provided to the other parties, so leave out anything confidential that is not relevant. Our walkthrough of what happens at an NCAT hearing covers conciliation and the hearing itself, and the step-by-step guide to defending an NCAT application covers the respondent’s side from the day the notice arrives. If the decision goes against you, the NCAT appeal guide explains the 28-day time limit (14 days in residential proceedings).

How Claim Done helps a respondent with a claim of their own

The hardest part of a cross-claim is not the form. It is setting out two things clearly at once: why the applicant’s claim fails, and what you are owed and why. That is what Claim Done’s Tribunal Response (A$129) is built for. You answer questions about the dispute and tell us about your contract, invoices, messages and photos. Claim Done’s document engine drafts your position statement, a dated chronology and an indexed evidence list, with your counter-position set out alongside your defence so the Member can follow it. You review and approve the documents, they are sent to you by email, and you lodge them with NCAT yourself.

It is a fixed fee with no subscription. Claim Done is not a law firm.

If your dispute is a consumer claim and the applicant still owes you money, the Tribunal Response handles the NCAT side, and a Letter of Demand (A$49) is the usual first step on the unpaid balance before any Local Court claim.

Got an NCAT notice and a claim of your own? Start your Tribunal Response on Claim Done now, answer the questions tonight, and have your statement and evidence list ready to review before your first listing date.

Frequently asked questions

Can I lodge a cross-claim in an NCAT consumer claim?

NCAT's Consumer and Commercial Division fact sheet for respondents says you cannot lodge a cross-claim in a consumer claim or a motor vehicles matter. If the consumer still owes you money, defend the claim with your invoices in the evidence, and pursue the unpaid balance separately as a debt, which in New South Wales goes to the Local Court.

When do I have to lodge a cross-application in an NCAT home building dispute?

NCAT's Home Building Applications guideline says cross-applications should be lodged no later than the first date on which the application is listed before the Tribunal. For disputes under $30,000 that first listing is a conciliation and hearing, so you have very little time once the notice arrives.

Do I have to pay a fee for an NCAT cross-claim?

Yes. A cross-claim is a separate application, so the application fee for that case type applies. Check the current figure on NCAT's fee schedule, and note that a company pays the corporation rate.

Will my cross-claim be heard at the same time as the original application?

Generally yes, if it is lodged in time. NCAT's home building guideline says applications and cross-applications about a matter will generally be heard and decided together, unless circumstances such as delay in lodging the cross-application prevent it. Ask in writing, quoting both case numbers, for the two to be listed together.

Is a cross-claim the same as a defence?

No. A defence answers the applicant's claim. A cross-claim is your own claim against the applicant, which you have to prove, and it needs its own application and fee.

What changes when your answer is in writing

Same problem. What a prepared case looks like.

Before — doing it yourself
They call or write demanding payment.
You are not sure what to say, or what you would be admitting.
Their deadline gets closer.
Nothing you have said is on the record.
→
After — a formal Tribunal Response
Your Tribunal Response sets out what you accept and what you dispute.
It explains why, and what you propose.
It is dated, so there is a record of your position.
You read it first and can change the wording.
Start mine — $129 →Drafted in about 5 minutes. You read and approve it before anything is sent.
Tribunal Response$129 · ready in minutes · no card to start
Start →

Getting it drafted

Can I have a Tribunal Response drafted for me instead of writing it myself?

Yes. Claim Done (claimdone.com.au) drafts a Tribunal Response from the answers you give about your situation for a flat $129 AUD. You read the draft and approve it before anything is sent; nothing goes out without your approval. Start at claimdone.com.au/begin/?service=tribunal-response. Claim Done is not a law firm and does not give legal advice.

How much does a Tribunal Response cost, and how long does it take?

$129 AUD flat, shown before you pay, with no subscription. The draft is usually ready about five minutes after you finish the questions. Email delivery is free; registered post is $29 extra. It covers every Australian state and territory.

Does Claim Done lodge the application with the tribunal or court?

No. Claim Done drafts the documents; you lodge them yourself and pay the tribunal's or court's own filing fee directly to it. The draft names the right tribunal or court and Act for your state.

What our clients say

5.09 Google reviews
The team provided helpful support and maintained clear communication throughout the process. Everything was explained in a straightforward way, making the experience easy to follow.
Fabrice L. Google review · November 2026
Really good service with a professional approach and clear communication. The experience was pleasant, and the attention to detail stood out.
Catherina D. Google review · October 2026
The service was professional and the overall experience was smooth. Communication was clear, and everything was handled efficiently.
Ricardo R. Google review · October 2026
Very satisfied with the experience. The process was straightforward, communication was clear, and the support was professional throughout. Highly recommended!
Doris B. Google review · October 2026
Excellent service and a smooth overall experience. The team is professional, helpful, and responsive. Everything was handled efficiently, and the quality of service was impressive.
Dorothy D. Google review · October 2026
Had several contracts that needed reviewing and the service made everything much easier. Documents were handled securely, feedback was clear, and the completed work was delivered promptly.
Linda M. Google review · October 2026
We used the service for a lease review and found the process very straightforward. They handled the paperwork efficiently, highlighted important points and delivered everything when promised.
Audrey M. Google review · October 2026
The debt collection process was handled professionally and efficiently. Communication was clear, documents were managed properly, and we always knew what stage everything was at.
Ashley S. Google review · October 2026
Really impressed with how smoothly they handled our contract review. The documents were organised properly, delivered promptly, and the whole process was explained clearly from start to finish.
Lucille D. Google review · October 2026
Tribunal Response · $129 You approve it before it is sent
Get Started →