Amazon Won’t Refund a Faulty Item? Your Rights in Australia (and How to Enforce Them)

The product broke after five weeks. Amazon’s return window closed at 30 days, and the bot says “this item is not eligible for return”. Or you returned it, tracking shows Amazon received it, and the refund never arrived. Or it was a third-party seller and Amazon says it’s “not responsible” while the seller doesn’t reply. You’re stuck in a loop of chat agents pasting the same policy.

Amazon’s return policy is not the law. The Australian Consumer Law is the law, and it doesn’t have a 30-day window. Here’s how to use that.

Your rights

• Consumer guarantees don’t expire at 30 days. Under the ACL, goods must be of acceptable quality (s 54), which means they must last as long as a reasonable consumer would expect for that price and type. A $300 appliance failing at week five is likely to be a major failure if a reasonable consumer would not have bought it knowing of the fault (s 260). If it is, you’re entitled to a refund or replacement (s 259), regardless of what Amazon’s page says. “Not eligible for return” is not a legal position.
• Amazon is the supplier for items sold by Amazon AU. Amazon Commercial Services Pty Ltd is the retailer and bears the guarantee obligations. For marketplace sellers, the seller is the supplier, but Amazon’s A-to-z Guarantee covers you, and Amazon can be liable for misleading conduct in how it presents the seller.
• The manufacturer is also liable (s 271 ACL). For goods not of acceptable quality, you can claim against the manufacturer or importer directly for damages, including the price paid.
• Refunds must be in the original form. A supplier can’t force you to accept a gift card or credit for a major failure. Cash back to your payment method is your right.
• Misleading conduct (s 18 ACL). Telling you that you have “no rights” after 30 days, or that you must deal with the manufacturer, is a misrepresentation about your consumer rights (s 29(1)(m) ACL specifically prohibits false representations about the existence or effect of a guarantee). The ACCC has fined retailers for this.

What to do right now

1. Document the fault. Photos or video of the defect, the order number, the date received, and the product listing. Note whether it was “Sold by Amazon AU” or a marketplace seller.
2. Contact Amazon in writing and cite the ACL. Use the chat or email, not the phone. Say: “This item has a major failure under the Australian Consumer Law. I require a refund under s 259 ACL. The 30-day return policy does not limit my statutory rights.” Ask the agent to escalate to a supervisor if refused. Save the transcript.
3. For missing refunds on returns, provide the tracking. If Amazon’s own tracking shows receipt, they’re holding your money. Demand the refund within 7 days.
4. Use the A-to-z Guarantee for marketplace items. You have 90 days from the estimated delivery date. Open it, attach evidence, and state the ACL breach.
5. Chargeback. If Amazon won’t refund a returned item or a clearly faulty one, your bank can reverse the charge. Provide the transcript showing the refusal.
6. Send a Letter of Demand. For higher-value items or repeated refusals, a formal letter to Amazon Commercial Services Pty Ltd (Sydney) citing ss 54, 259 and 29(1)(m) ACL, with a 14-day deadline before an ACCC report and tribunal claim, gets routed to their legal or compliance team. They know the ACCC watches this.

Scripts that work with Amazon support

Amazon’s agents follow scripts. Yours needs to be clearer than theirs. Some phrasings that tend to get results:

• For a faulty item outside 30 days: “Under the Australian Consumer Law, section 54, this product must be of acceptable quality, which includes lasting a reasonable time. It has failed after [X weeks]. I believe this is a major failure under section 260. I am entitled to a refund under section 259. Amazon’s 30-day policy does not limit this right. Please process the refund or escalate to a supervisor who can.”
• For a return Amazon received but hasn’t refunded: “Your tracking shows the return was received on [date]. Amazon has had the item and my money for [X] days. Please refund to my original payment method within 48 hours or I will initiate a chargeback and report to the ACCC.”
• When told to contact the manufacturer: “Section 29(1)(m) of the ACL prohibits misrepresenting a consumer’s rights. Amazon is the supplier and is responsible for the guarantee. I am not required to contact the manufacturer.”
• When offered a gift card: “I do not accept a gift card. The refund must be to my original payment method.”

Ask for a transcript to be emailed at the end of every chat, or copy it yourself. If the agent ends the chat, start another and reference the previous one.

Marketplace sellers. “Sold by [X], fulfilled by Amazon” means the seller is the supplier, but Amazon handled the money and the logistics. The A-to-z Guarantee is Amazon’s promise to make you whole if the seller won’t. If the A-to-z claim is refused, appeal it (you get one appeal), then chargeback.

Items lost in delivery. If Amazon’s tracking says delivered and it wasn’t, they’re usually quick to refund or replace once. Repeated “delivered but not received” issues at one address get flagged, so if it’s a pattern at your address, photograph where parcels are being left and report to Amazon and the carrier.

Who to complain to

ACCC (misrepresenting consumer rights), your state fair trading / consumer affairs office, and for a refused chargeback, AFCA. Money claims: your state civil tribunal, naming Amazon Commercial Services Pty Ltd or the marketplace seller’s Australian entity. For manufacturer claims, the Australian importer listed on the packaging.

Start your claim — $49

Claim Done drafts your Letter of Demand in about 5 minutes for $49. Tell us what happened — we handle the legal language.

Start My Claim — $49 →

You approve it before anything is sent.