Private School Won’t Refund Fees After You Withdrew? Here’s How to Fight It

You withdrew your child, maybe because you moved, maybe because the school wasn’t working out, maybe because you simply couldn’t afford it anymore. Now the school is invoicing you for a full term’s fees “in lieu of notice”, refusing to refund the deposit, or threatening debt collectors over a child who isn’t even enrolled there.

Schools frame this as “our policy”. But a school enrolment contract is still a consumer contract, and the same rules about unfair terms and penalties that apply to gyms and telcos apply to them.

Your rights

• Unfair contract terms (ss 23–28 ACL). Enrolment contracts are standard-form consumer contracts. A term requiring a full term’s (or year’s) fees for withdrawal, with no reduction for the school’s ability to fill the place, can be an unfair term and void. The test: does it cause significant imbalance, is it reasonably necessary to protect the school’s legitimate interests, and does it cause you detriment? A blanket “one term’s fees” clause frequently fails that test, especially for popular schools with waiting lists.
• Penalty clauses. Under general contract law (Paciocco v ANZ), a fee that’s out of all proportion to the school’s legitimate interest in the notice term being kept may be an unenforceable penalty. If they filled your child’s place, ask what interest a full term’s fees still protects.
• Consumer guarantees (ss 60–61 ACL). Education is a service. If the school failed to provide what was promised (a program, support for a learning need, a safe environment), you may be entitled to end the contract for a major failure and claim a refund.
• Misleading conduct (s 18 ACL). If the enrolment materials or interviews promised things the school didn’t deliver, that’s relevant to both your withdrawal and any refund.
• Debt collection conduct. If the school sends the “debt” to a collector, the ACCC/ASIC Debt Collection Guideline applies, and a disputed debt should not be listed as a default without proper process.

What to do right now

1. Get the enrolment contract and fee schedule. Read the withdrawal clause carefully. Note whether it distinguishes between reasons for withdrawal, and whether it says anything about mitigation (the school filling the place).
2. Confirm your notice in writing. If you haven’t already, send a dated email confirming the withdrawal date. Ask the school to confirm whether the place has been or will be filled.
3. Document your reasons. If you withdrew because the school failed your child (bullying not addressed, promised support not provided, program cancelled), gather emails and meeting notes. That supports a consumer-guarantee argument.
4. Dispute the invoice in writing. State that you dispute the fees in lieu of notice as an unfair contract term and an unenforceable penalty, and that any deposit should be refunded. Ask them to hold collection while the dispute is resolved.
5. Send a Letter of Demand. A formal letter citing ss 23–28 ACL, the penalty doctrine, and (where relevant) the consumer guarantees, demanding withdrawal of the invoice and refund of any deposit, with a 14-day deadline, tends to reach the business manager or board rather than the accounts office. Schools are sensitive to reputational risk and regulatory complaints.
6. Escalate. Complain to your state fair trading body. If the school is a member of an independent schools association or under a diocesan authority, complain there too. Then file at the tribunal if they pursue you or won’t refund.

How schools argue it, and how you answer

• “The notice period lets us plan staffing and budgets.” That’s a legitimate interest, but the question is proportionality. One term’s notice with fees reducing if the place is filled might be reasonable. A full term’s fees with no adjustment, regardless of whether they’ve filled the spot from a waiting list, may be a penalty.
• “You signed the enrolment agreement.” Signing an unfair term doesn’t make it fair. The ACL regime exists precisely for standard-form contracts you had no ability to negotiate.
• “Everyone else pays it.” Irrelevant. Many people pay unfair fees because they don’t know they can challenge them.
• “The deposit is non-refundable.” A deposit that is out of all proportion to the school’s legitimate interest in the enrolment going ahead may be an unenforceable penalty.

Where the school failed your child. This changes the analysis completely. If you withdrew because the school didn’t provide a promised program, failed to address serious bullying, or couldn’t accommodate a disclosed learning need, you’re not “changing your mind”: you’re ending a contract the school breached. In that case you can also seek a refund of fees already paid for the period of failure.

Financial hardship. Most schools have a hardship policy and a bursary or fee-relief process. If the real issue is affordability, ask for it in writing alongside your dispute; schools would generally rather negotiate than litigate a family in hardship.

Reputation. Independent schools care enormously about how they’re seen by prospective parents. A formal, measured Letter of Demand (not a social media campaign) tends to reach the principal or business manager and produce a negotiated outcome.

Who to complain to

State fair trading / consumer affairs (NSW Fair Trading, Consumer Affairs Victoria, Queensland OFT, etc.). ACCC for unfair contract terms in school contracts (they have flagged this sector). For non-government schools, the relevant Association of Independent Schools or Catholic Education Office. For registration and standards issues, the New South Wales Education Standards Authority, VRQA (Victoria), or Non-State Schools Accreditation Board (Queensland). Disputed debts: your state civil tribunal.

Start your claim — $49

Claim Done drafts your Letter of Demand in about 5 minutes for $49. Tell us what happened — we handle the legal language.

Start My Claim — $49 →

You approve it before anything is sent.