If SACAT has sent you a Notice naming you as the respondent, someone has applied to the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal about a dispute with you. It may be a landlord or a tenant. Read the Notice today, note the date of the conference or hearing, gather the documents it asks for, set out your side in writing, and attend. If you do not take part, SACAT can decide the matter without you.
Claim Done drafts a Tribunal Response from your answers for a flat A$129: a response summary, a defence position statement, a chronology and an evidence list, ready for you to check, lodge with SACAT and take to the conference or hearing. It is for SACAT applications, such as residential tenancy matters. It is not for a claim in the Magistrates Court.
First, check it really is a SACAT application
People mix these up, and the difference matters. SACAT hears residential tenancy, rooming house, residential park and retirement village tenancy disputes up to $40,000, according to its jurisdiction list. A money claim lodged in the Magistrates Court is a court claim, not a tribunal application. The Courts Administration Authority says its minor claims division covers debts up to $12,000, and that if a respondent has not responded after 28 days, the applicant can ask for judgment.
| Papers come from | What it is | Is this guide for you? |
|---|---|---|
| SACAT (a Notice with a copy of the application) | A tribunal application, such as a tenancy dispute | Yes |
| The Magistrates Court (a claim, such as a minor claim) | A court claim with its own response rules | No. Contact the court registry or a lawyer straight away |
The name on the first page tells you which one you have. Claim Done does not prepare court defences.
What SACAT sends you
SACAT says it will send you a Notice with a copy of the application and any supporting documents the applicant gave it. Its page on how to respond to an application lists what the Notice tells you:
- the type of application made against you
- whether you must attend a conference, directions hearing or final hearing
- the date, time and place of it
- the information or documents you need to provide.
What you have to attend and provide depends on the issue. So the Notice, not a general guide, is your checklist. SACAT must accept every application within its jurisdiction, so being named does not mean SACAT agrees with the applicant. It only means an application has been made against you.
Ready to put it in writing?
Answer 3 quick questions to check you have the details your document needs, and see your next step.
1. Who is the claim or demand from?
2. How much are they claiming?
3. Do you have it in writing?
Your result is ready. Want a copy by email? (optional)
Common tenancy applications you might be answering
- End of tenancy. SACAT says the most common dispute is a landlord’s claim on the bond, or for compensation, because the property was not returned in an appropriate condition. Claims can include rent, water, cleaning and repairs. A tenant can also apply for the bond to be repaid.
- Breach. For a simple breach, the other party should first give a notice asking for it to be fixed. If it is not fixed in time, they may apply to end the agreement. A landlord can also apply urgently for serious breach, such as significant rent arrears, serious damage or injury.
Whichever it is, start on the paperwork straight away.
What your written response should cover
A clear written response helps you, the applicant and the member see exactly what is in dispute. Make sure yours covers:
- The case number, the parties and the property address.
- Each thing the applicant claims, in the order they claim it.
- For each one: whether you agree, partly agree or disagree, and why.
- Anything you accept, and any amount you accept you owe.
- The key dates in order: the lease, the notices, the inspections, the payments, the move-out.
- The documents and witnesses that back up each point.
- The outcome you are asking for.
Documents to gather
SACAT’s checklist for housing documents starts with the tenancy agreement and any notice of breach. Depending on the dispute, it also lists:
| Dispute | Documents SACAT lists |
|---|---|
| Rent | The rent record |
| Bond or compensation at the end of a tenancy | A summary of claims, inspection sheets, photos, invoices, quotes, rent records, break lease calculations, witnesses |
| Parties’ rights | Emails, letters and texts about the dispute, photos, inspection sheets, invoices, witnesses |
Any evidence you give SACAT and ask the member to consider must also be given to the other party. If a document holds confidential information that is not relevant, you can ask for it to be redacted, but SACAT will still ask for a full copy as well.
How the response pack is set out
The Tribunal Response comes as four separate documents. Each is built like this:
- Response summary. The parties, the case number if you give it, what the applicant is claiming, your overall position, and what you ask SACAT to order.
- Defence position statement. A point-by-point answer to the claim: what you admit, what you deny and your side of the facts, and any other defence you raise.
- Chronology. A dated list of events in time order, one row each.
- Evidence list. Each document, photo and message you list, numbered, dated and described, so you can point to it quickly.
The conference
Your Notice may require you to attend a conference, a chance to discuss the issues and try to reach agreement. The member or deputy registrar running it is not an advisor for either side and will not impose a decision. SACAT asks you to attend in person. Attending by phone or video may be possible in special circumstances, but needs its permission before the conference. Lodge your documents before the conference and bring them, with any extras.
Three rules matter most. What is said at a conference cannot be relied on in other proceedings without everyone’s consent. Any agreement is binding and becomes a SACAT order, so only agree to what you can do. And if you do not attend, or you obstruct the process, a decision may be made against you. The SACAT Act 2013 (section 50) gives the member presiding at a compulsory conference that power. If the dispute is not settled, it goes to a hearing before a different member.
The hearing
At a SACAT hearing, the applicant usually presents first and you then respond. You can give a written submission to the member and the other parties. The decision is binding, may be enforced, and you get it in writing. Under section 39 of the Act, hearings run with the minimum of formality and SACAT is not bound by the rules of evidence.
When preparing for a hearing, bring all relevant documents, photos and witnesses. Once it is over, you may not be able to reopen the case. In a tenancy dispute you generally cannot have a lawyer represent you without SACAT’s permission, which is given only in exceptional circumstances. If you cannot attend, tell SACAT why as soon as possible. If it refuses to reschedule, the hearing goes ahead without you.
If you missed it, or disagree with the decision
If you had a reasonable excuse for missing a hearing, such as not receiving notice of it, you can apply for a review for non-attendance, usually within 7 days of the decision. SACAT says having work may not be a reasonable excuse. If you simply disagree with a decision, most housing decisions can go to an internal review, lodged within one calendar month of the decision. The Act says a review of a decision made in SACAT’s original jurisdiction needs leave of a legally qualified member.
Mistakes to avoid
- Treating a Magistrates Court claim as a SACAT matter, or the other way round.
- Putting the Notice aside and missing the conference date.
- Answering in one long story instead of point by point.
- Sending documents to SACAT but not to the other party.
- Agreeing at a conference to terms you cannot keep.
- Leaving evidence at home on hearing day.
Polite, reasonable contact with the other party can still settle a dispute before the hearing, unless contact would be unwise or unsafe. Whatever happens, turn up with your side in writing. Start your SACAT response now: answer the questions, check the four documents, and lodge them with SACAT before your conference.
What changes when your answer is in writing
Same problem. What a prepared case looks like.
Getting it drafted
Can I have a Tribunal Response drafted for me instead of writing it myself?
Yes. Claim Done (claimdone.com.au) drafts a Tribunal Response from the answers you give about your situation for a flat $129 AUD. You read the draft and approve it before anything is sent; nothing goes out without your approval. Start at claimdone.com.au/begin/?service=tribunal-response. Claim Done is not a law firm and does not give legal advice.
How much does a Tribunal Response cost, and how long does it take?
$129 AUD flat, shown before you pay, with no subscription. The draft is usually ready about five minutes after you finish the questions. Email delivery is free; registered post is $29 extra. It covers every Australian state and territory.
Does Claim Done lodge the application with the tribunal or court?
No. Claim Done drafts the documents; you lodge them yourself and pay the tribunal's or court's own filing fee directly to it. The draft names the right tribunal or court and Act for your state.