Landlord Ignored Repairs for Months: Can I Claim Compensation (and How Much)?

The hot water system died in June. You reported it the same day, again a week later, again by email with photos. The agent said “we’ve sent it to the owner”. Winter came and went with cold showers. The oven stopped in August; that’s “with the owner” too. You’ve paid full rent every fortnight for a home that doesn’t do what a home is supposed to do.

Tenants tend to think compensation is something you ask for at the end, if at all. It isn’t. Every state gives you a right to compensation for the landlord’s breach, measured by what you lost, and the tribunals award it, including for the months already gone.

Your rights

Every tenancy statute requires the landlord to provide and maintain the premises in reasonable repair, and to carry out urgent repairs (hot water, heating, cooking, water, sewerage, gas or electrical faults, roof leaks, security) promptly. When they don’t, you have three remedies, and you can use them together: an order compelling the repairs; an order reducing rent for the period the premises were sub-standard; and compensation for loss, which includes the difference between what you paid and what the premises were worth, any property damaged (clothes ruined by mould, food lost when the fridge circuit failed), out-of-pocket costs (laundromat, takeaway, a heater), and in some states inconvenience and distress. You don’t have to move out to claim; and claiming is not a ground for eviction, in any state.

By state

• New South Wales. Residential Tenancies Act 2010, s 63 (repairs) and s 187 (orders). Apply to NCAT for repair orders, a rent reduction and compensation. Apply while you’re still in the property or soon after; bond-related claims must be within 6 months of the tenancy ending.
• Victoria. Residential Tenancies Act 1997, s 68 (repairs), s 209 (compensation up to $10,000 per breach of duty). Apply to VCAT; the compensation claim must be brought within 6 years of the loss.
• Queensland. RTRA Act 2008, s 185 (lessor’s repair obligations), s 419 (time limit). Serve Form 11 first, then apply to the RTA’s dispute resolution and QCAT. Compensation claims must be filed within 6 months of becoming aware of the breach.
• Western Australia. Residential Tenancies Act 1987, s 42 (repairs). Serve a breach notice on the prescribed form, then apply to the Magistrates Court for repair orders, rent reduction and compensation.
• South Australia. Residential Tenancies Act 1995, s 68 (repairs), s 110 (orders). Apply to SACAT for repairs, rent abatement and compensation.
• Tasmania. Residential Tenancy Act 1997 (owner’s repair obligations). Apply to the Magistrates Court (Residential Tenancy jurisdiction) for repair orders and compensation; the Residential Tenancy Commissioner handles bond and some inspection matters.
• Australian Capital Territory. Residential Tenancies Act 1997 standard terms (repairs), s 83 (orders). Apply to ACAT for repairs, rent reduction and compensation.
• Northern Territory. Residential Tenancies Act 1999 (landlord’s repair obligations), s 122 (compensation). Apply to NTCAT.

The Claim Done document asks your state first and drafts the demand to that state’s repair obligations, time limits and tribunal.

What to do right now

1. Assemble the timeline. Every report you made (date, method, to whom), every response, every photo. The gap between first report and today is the period you’re claiming for.
2. Put a number on it. Rent paid over the period, multiplied by the percentage of the home you lost. No hot water in winter, no heating, no cooking, or a bedroom unusable from mould is valued as a percentage reflecting the lost use. Add out-of-pocket receipts and damaged property.
3. Serve a formal breach and compensation demand. Cite the repair section, list the repairs still outstanding with a deadline, state the compensation figure with the calculation, give 14 days, and name the tribunal.
4. Apply for repair orders in parallel if it’s urgent. Most tribunals hear urgent repair applications within days. You don’t have to wait for the landlord’s 14 days to run.
5. File the compensation application inside the time limit. Queensland’s 6 months is the tightest. Don’t let “the owner is getting quotes” run you past it.

How tribunals actually calculate rent reduction

Tribunals ask a simple question: what was the premises worth to live in, compared with what you paid? They don’t use a formula, but they follow patterns. A single non-essential fault (a broken dishwasher) gets a small percentage. Loss of an essential service (hot water, heating in a cold climate, the only bathroom) gets a substantial one, a percentage reflecting the lost use for the period. Total loss of amenity (unliveable rooms, sewage, no power) can approach 100%. Present your claim that way: period, percentage, rent, total. It’s the language the member is already thinking in.

Who to complain to

Your tribunal first: NCAT, VCAT, QCAT (after RTA conciliation), the Magistrates Court (Western Australia and Tasmania), SACAT, ACAT, NTCAT. In parallel, your state’s Fair Trading or Consumer Affairs body can take a complaint about the agent’s conduct (and, in New South Wales and Victoria, minimum-standards or rental-safety breaches), and a tenants’ advice service in every state can check your figures for free.

Claim the rent you overpaid — $49

Claim Done drafts a Tenant Compensation Claim that sets out the repair history, the section the landlord breached, the repairs still required by a deadline, and a calculated compensation and rent-reduction figure with 14 days to pay before you file.

Claim Compensation From My Landlord — $49 →

You review every word before it’s sent.