02 8880 1347
← Tribunal cases Published

Claim of $1,080.32 against a mechanic dismissed for lack of evidence of poor work (QCAT, 2026)

A vehicle owner sought $1,080.32 from a mobile diesel mechanic for towing, parts and a labour charge connected with two repair episodes on a Mazda BT-50 in 2022 and 2024. The tribunal dismissed the claim because the owner did not prove that the mechanic's work or advice fell below the required standard, or that the costs were caused by any failure on the mechanic's part.

Not sure what you need? Just tell us what happened. Describe it in plain English and our chat builds the right document for you — no forms, no legal jargon.

Drafted from your answers in minutes · you review it before anything is sent · Private & encrypted

Topics: Consumer vs tradesperson, Motor vehicle dealers, QCAT, Queensland

Decision: [2026] QCAT 450, 30 September 2026
Dispute: Consumer vs tradesperson
Outcome: Application dismissed
Where are you up to?
Pick the closest one and we’ll start the right document for you. You see the price and approve it before anything is sent.
Not ready yet? Get the free checklist for your stage
A one-page checklist by email, with the official links for your tribunal.

What happened

The owner of a Mazda BT-50 used a sole-trader mechanic several times between 2022 and 2024 for repairs and maintenance. The claim arose from two separate episodes.

In August 2022 the vehicle broke down at Enoggera. The mechanic came out but could not restart it, and it was towed to the owner's home. The owner said the mechanic told him at the roadside that a sprocket had come off the fuel pump because the mechanic had not used thread-locking compound when he fitted it earlier. The mechanic denied saying this. He said the cause was a design flaw in the part, which the manufacturer later modified. The owner sent a reimbursement demand on 2 January 2023. About three months later he engaged the mechanic again for further paid work. The tribunal found no record of the owner pressing that debt again until he filed his claim about 18 months later.

In March 2024 the owner reported a loss of coolant. The mechanic said that when asked whether it could be the radiator, he replied it was 'probably' the radiator but that he could not see and did not know. The owner then bought a new radiator, coolant and hose clamps himself, and asked the mechanic to fit the radiator and hoses. The mechanic fitted the radiator, a lower radiator hose and a bypass hose. He charged three hours of labour at $90 an hour, a total of $270.

The claim was first filed in the Caboolture Magistrates Court on 28 June 2024 and later moved to the tribunal's motor vehicle list. Neither party gave oral evidence at the hearing. Both relied on their written material and documents.

What each side wanted

The owner claimed $1,080.32 in total: $253.00 for towing, $118.13 for a replacement sprocket, $275.00 for a radiator, $106.72 for two hoses (his own invoice recorded $97.02 for the same item), $47.47 for coolant and hose clamps, $270.00 for the mechanic's March 2024 labour charge, which he said was excessive because the work should have taken under 30 minutes, and $10.00 for a business-name search. The mechanic denied liability for all of it. He said the sprocket failed because of a design flaw in the part, not his workmanship. He said he never diagnosed the radiator or told the owner to buy one, and that fitting both hoses is standard trade practice for this kind of repair. He also said his labour charge reflected the work actually done. In emails he said he had 'never received any services' from the owner's business and owed it nothing.

Free · 30 seconds

Ready to put it in writing?

Answer 3 quick questions to check you have the details your document needs, and see your next step.

1. Who owes you?

Give us a name — even a first name or business name is fine.

2. How much?

3. Do you have it in writing?

Your result is ready. Want a copy by email? (optional)

That email does not look right.
Leave it blank to see your result now. Add your email and we also send you the result and your next step, so you can come back to it. No spam, no list.

Continue to your $49 Consumer Guarantee Letter →
Your answers are carried across — you will not have to type them again. You read and confirm it before it is final. Nothing is sent to anyone else. No card needed to start.

What the tribunal decided

The tribunal dismissed the application. It found that the owner had not proved any part of the $1,080.32 claimed. Each party was ordered to bear their own costs, meaning each pays their own expenses of the case.

Consumer Guarantee Letter — $49You review it first · Nothing is sent to anyone else · Ready in about 5 min
6,259 people visited ClaimDone in the past 30 days
A formal demand with a clear deadline is often the first step before a tribunal or court claim.
I'll draft your Consumer Guarantee Letter right now. Which business owes you a refund?
No card needed to start · Type a name and hit send

Why the tribunal decided it that way

The tribunal assessed the claim under the consumer guarantees in the Australian Consumer Law. Section 60 guarantees that services are provided with due care and skill. Section 61 guarantees that services will be fit for a purpose the consumer made known, but under s 61(3) this applies only where the consumer relied on the supplier's skill or judgment and it was reasonable to do so. If a guarantee is breached, the consumer can recover consequential loss under s 267. Consequential loss means costs that flow from the failure. The owner had to prove each part of his claim on the balance of probabilities, which means showing it was more likely than not. Following the High Court case Briginshaw v Briginshaw, the tribunal said a serious allegation calls for more careful proof. One example is a claim that a tradesperson admitted faulty work.

On the sprocket, the only evidence of the alleged roadside admission was the owner's own account, written after the event. The mechanic flatly denied making it. The tribunal said this disputed, unrecorded conversation was not enough. It also gave weight to the fact that the owner kept using the mechanic for paid work soon after his demand, and did not raise the debt again for about 18 months. As a result, the tribunal was not satisfied that the failure was caused by a lack of care rather than a fault in the part. Because the towing and sprocket costs depended on that finding, they could not be recovered either.

On the radiator, the tribunal accepted that the mechanic gave only a qualified opinion ('probably', but he could not see), not a firm diagnosis. That was not a breach of the duty of due care and skill. The tribunal also found it was not reasonable reliance under s 61(3) to spend $275 on a radiator based on such a hedged remark. The mechanic's evidence that fitting both hoses is normal trade practice was not contradicted. The owner's own documents gave two different figures for the hoses, with no explanation. Because no breach was proved, the coolant and clamps were simply costs of a repair the owner chose to have done.

On the labour charge, the owner did not dispute that the invoiced work was done. He offered no independent quote, trade guide or expert opinion to show three hours was unreasonable. The tribunal would not prefer his unsupported lay opinion on a technical question over the mechanic's itemised invoice. The $10 search fee was unnecessary because the mechanic's invoice already showed his business name, ABN and address. The tribunal read the mechanic's 'never received any services' emails as a rejection of the owner's confusing invoice, not as a denial that the two had ever dealt with each other. That invoice had been issued in three different amounts with no description. Overall, the owner's documents proved what he had spent, but not that the mechanic caused those costs through any failure.

What this means if you are in a similar position

This decision shows that, in a consumer guarantee claim about repair work, receipts on their own prove only what you spent. If you are in a similar position, the tribunal will usually look for evidence that the work or advice actually fell short and that your costs flowed from that failure. Examples of that evidence are a written report or quote from another mechanic, an expert opinion, a witness, or a written admission. A disputed, unrecorded conversation may carry little weight where the other side denies it.

The decision also shows how the tribunal treats a casual or hedged opinion such as 'probably the radiator'. Relying on that kind of remark to buy parts may not count as reasonable reliance on the tradesperson's skill. Your own conduct can also be weighed. In this case that included continuing to use the same business and not pursuing a claim for a long period. Clear, consistent paperwork matters too. Invoices that change amount or do not explain what they are for can count against the person relying on them.

In disputes like this, the first step most people take is to set out the problem and the amount sought in a clear written demand, with supporting documents attached. If that does not resolve it, they then consider an application to the tribunal.

How to apply: our step-by-step guide to a QCAT application. More decisions: QCAT cases and motor vehicle dealers.

Source: David John Arnold v Ross Thomas Cooper [2026] QCAT 450 (read the full decision). This summary was prepared from the published decision for general information. It is not legal advice, and the tribunal’s own reasons are the authoritative record.

Start this type of case

CONSUMER VS TRADESPERSON

In a similar position? A written demand under the consumer guarantees sets out the alleged repair failure, the costs sought and the evidence before any tribunal claim. Claim Done drafts a Consumer Guarantee Letter from your answers for $49. Describe what happened in a sentence or two; you read and approve it before anything is sent.

Start my consumer guarantee letter →Already past that step? Start a tribunal application ($97) →No card needed to start. Not legal advice; the tribunal decides each matter on its facts.

What happens when you send a Consumer Guarantee Letter

Same problem. What a prepared case looks like.

Before — doing it yourself
You text them. They ignore you.
You email again. "Sorry, been busy."
Weeks pass. Nothing changes.
You start to feel like the annoying one.
→
After — a formal Consumer Guarantee Letter
A formal legal letter lands in their inbox.
It cites the Act, the amount, and the interest.
It gives them a clear deadline to pay.
If they do not, you have the paper trail a tribunal or court will ask for.
Send mine — $49 →Drafted in about 5 minutes. You read and confirm it before it is final. Nothing is sent to anyone else.
Consumer Guarantee Letter$49 · ready in minutes · no card to start
Start →

Getting it drafted

Can I have a Consumer Guarantee Letter drafted for me instead of writing it myself?

Yes. Claim Done (claimdone.com.au) drafts a Consumer Guarantee Letter from the answers you give about your situation for a flat $49 AUD. You read and confirm the draft, then the final PDF is emailed to you. Start at claimdone.com.au/begin/?service=consumer-guarantee. Claim Done is not a law firm and does not give legal advice.

How much does a Consumer Guarantee Letter cost, and how long does it take?

$49 AUD flat, shown before you pay, with no subscription. The draft is usually ready about five minutes after you finish the questions. It covers every Australian state and territory.

Do I need a lawyer to send a Consumer Guarantee Letter in Australia?

No. There is no legal requirement to use a solicitor to write or send a Consumer Guarantee Letter; many people send their own. Claim Done drafts it for you and you approve it before it is sent.

What our clients say

5.09 Google reviews
The team provided helpful support and maintained clear communication throughout the process. Everything was explained in a straightforward way, making the experience easy to follow.
Fabrice L. Google review · November 2026
Really good service with a professional approach and clear communication. The experience was pleasant, and the attention to detail stood out.
Catherina D. Google review · October 2026
The service was professional and the overall experience was smooth. Communication was clear, and everything was handled efficiently.
Ricardo R. Google review · October 2026
Very satisfied with the experience. The process was straightforward, communication was clear, and the support was professional throughout. Highly recommended!
Doris B. Google review · October 2026
Excellent service and a smooth overall experience. The team is professional, helpful, and responsive. Everything was handled efficiently, and the quality of service was impressive.
Dorothy D. Google review · October 2026
Had several contracts that needed reviewing and the service made everything much easier. Documents were handled securely, feedback was clear, and the completed work was delivered promptly.
Linda M. Google review · October 2026
We used the service for a lease review and found the process very straightforward. They handled the paperwork efficiently, highlighted important points and delivered everything when promised.
Audrey M. Google review · October 2026
The debt collection process was handled professionally and efficiently. Communication was clear, documents were managed properly, and we always knew what stage everything was at.
Ashley S. Google review · October 2026
Really impressed with how smoothly they handled our contract review. The documents were organised properly, delivered promptly, and the whole process was explained clearly from start to finish.
Lucille D. Google review · October 2026
Consumer Guarantee Letter · $49 You review it first · Nothing is sent to anyone else
Start My Demand →